Consider this a throwback post, in that it does what the blog started out doing, and that’s just trying to correct and fill out metadata around Garciavents. Here, I argue that the material we know from circulating tapes as 9/24/71 is actually from the next night, 9/25/71, also at the Lion’s Share in San Anselmo. The post also serves to pin down a third set of music from the four played this weekend, from newly digitized (and, as of today, circulated) tape of what, I argue, should be seen as the 9/24/71 late show.
Tom Fogerty left Creedence Clearwater Revival on February 1, 1971 (Boucher 1972), seeking to escape the domineering shadow of his little brother John and carve out his own musical identity. Around May 26, 1971, he first sat in with Jerry Garcia and Merl Saunders and their unnamed group, at the Keystone Korner in San Francisco. He gigged on and off with them for a year-and-a-half, while also doing all kinds of studio work at The House That Creedence Built (Fantasy in Berkeley). He continued collaborating on Merl’s Fire Up into late spring ’73 before exiting the Garciaverse. Some of his correspondence with Merl lives in the GD Archives, and from what we can glean he was a sweet and generous guy who was very fond of his labelmate. He continued to play and record through ongoing back problems, fell on some hard personal times, and apparently contracted HIV/AIDS from an unscreened blood transfusion connected with a back surgery in the early 80s. This led to his untimely demise from a tuberculosis infection at the age of 49 on September 6, 1990.
I have yet to come to a clear understanding of my own of the mix of music and commerce (especially, the role of Fantasy Records) in the “Tom Fogerty Era” of the Garcia-Saunders group, partly because, outside studio recordings, so few tapes of them playing live are available to hear. The first pop up almost four months after his arrival, in September 1971, with two widely-circulated sets from the Lion’s Share which I will focus on here. After that, the next tape comes June 30, 1972 at the Korner, and then December 28, 1972, again in San Anselmo. That’s it – though tape exists of September 20, 1971 at the Inn of the Beginning in Cotati, and December 5, 1972 at the Boarding House in the city, it does not circulate. And, while he figured in some billings early in 1973, it seems highly unlikely that he ever gigged with these guys after 1972.
We currently list 48 Tom Fogerty events at Jerrybase, we have a few setlists from newspaper reviews and attendee recollections, and now pieces of five shows. Tragically, all of our JB listings are for public events. Fantasy has remained completely opaque in terms of session dates, which I estimate might number in the few dozens from 1970 or 1971 through 1974 or 1975.
As a result of all of this, the little tape that we have is precious. I have spent considerable time with it trying to glean some insight into the Fogerty Era. It’s risky to extrapolate much from the little we can hear, of course. But it seems clear that he and Jerry shared a love for 50s R&B numbers such as Hank Ballard and the Midnighters’ “Annie Had A Baby” (1954), The Four Deuces’ “W-P-L-J” (1956), and Jimmy Reed’s straighter blues “Baby What You Want Me To Do?” (1959), the latter of which the Dead played a few times but none of which is known to have appeared in any other GOTS configuration. They also played Jesse Winchester’s super-sweet “Biloxi” from his 1970 debut, and a bunch of tunes that otherwise seem part of the Garcia-Saunders repertoire of the period, insofar as we can know it.
The Lion’s Share gigs on September 24-25, 1971 were well advertised and, in a refreshing change of pace, Fogerty’s name preceded Garcia’s. Yayyy, Jerry! (We celebrate this because the guy just wanted to play, he didn’t need or necessarily want top-billing). Maybe it was just done alphabetically. Anyway, only the Berkeley Tribe specifies early (9 PM) and late (11:30 PM) shows. The ads all identify Jerry Corbitt, Billy Cox, and Charlie Daniels (yes, the one you’ve heard of) opening, though for some reason Jerrybase currently shows Loading Zone and Congress of Wonders the first night instead of them. Gideon and Power were also on the bill the second night, per the Lion’s Share calendar.
My partner David Minches and I have just had the pleasure of working with 1971-1972 Lion’s Share soundman Lou Judson to arrange a fresh transfer of these old tapes. The three from this September 1971 weekend present, first, a Sony PR-150 labeled “Friday 24 Sept 71 last 1/2 hr)”.
The labeling is confirmed by the end of the recording, where the emcee says “Jerry Garcia, Merl Saunders, Tom Fogerty and Bill Kreutzmann. They’ll be back tomorrow night, for another two shows, along with Jerry Corbitt and Charlie Daniels. Come back and bring your friends. Thank you for comin’, and good night.” So this is clearly 9/24/71b. As you will hear when the seed hits the ether, this is distinct music that has never circulated among collectors.
It seems that there probably was a first reel from this night, but, alas, it remains MIA.
But wait, you say – don’t circulating filesets already purport to include 9/24/71b? Indeed, they do. But these tapes clearly establish that they are mis-dated, and derive from the second night. Lou’s other two reels from the weekend are Sony SLH-180 stock, and clearly labeled “September 25 Saturday ’71 first set” and “September 25, 1971 second set”.
The material on these tapes corresponds to the material that has long circulated as 9/24/71. But it is actually 9/25/71.
Last thing to do is pin down what we can from the partial setlist for 9/24/71b, and post listening notes from all three sets of material. That stuff follows.
~~~~~
Jerry Garcia and Merl Saunders
Lion’s Share
60 Red Hill Avenue
San Anselmo, CA 94960
September 24, 1971 (Friday) – Late Show / reel #2
Judson MSR > HD 2022
–end of late show (6 tracks, 5 tunes, 30:28)–
19710924-l-t01. [0:46] Annie Had A Baby [3:21] ->
19710924-l-t02. W-P-L-J [3:48] [1:07]
19710924-l-t03. Baby, What Do You Want Me To Do? [5:16] [1:08]
19710924-l-t04. I Was Made To Love Her [7:51] [1:05]
19710924-l-t05. The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down [5:31]
19710924-l-t06. outro (2) [0:36]
! ACT1: Jerry Garcia and Merl Saunders
! lineup: Jerry Garcia – electric guitar, vocals;
! lineup: Tom Fogerty – electric guitar, vocals;
! lineup: Merl Saunders – keyboards;
! lineup: Bill Kreutzmann – drums.
JGMF:
! Recording: symbols: % = recording discontinuity; / = clipped song; // = cut song; … = fade in/out; # = truncated timing; [m:ss] = recorded event time. The recorded event time immediately after the song or item name is an attempt at getting the “real” time of the event. So, a timing of [m:ss] right after a song title is an attempt to say how long the song really was, as represented on this recording.
! Jerrybase: https://jerrybase.com/events/19710924
! db: none in circulation from this date. The following are mistakenly dated 9/24/71, but are actually 9/25/71: https://etreedb.org/shn/4497 (early and late, via Shriver shnf); https://etreedb.org/shn/137584 (Reel Master 10inch Master [email protected] 1/2trk > DAT, via Eaton-Scotton-Miller-SirMick); https://etreedb.org/shn/138213 (raw version of shnid-137584)
! map: https://goo.gl/maps/FCaYZGNhk21VzhvF6
! JGBP: http://jerrygarciasbrokendownpalaces.blogspot.com/2012/06/lions-share-60-red-hill-avenue-san.html
! personnel: NB no bass.
! R: field recordist: Lou Judson
! R: field recording gear: PA line out > Viking 88
! R: field recording media: Sony PR-150 1/4″ x 7″ @7.5ips stereo (tape “GS6”)
! R: lineage: MSR Sony 854-4 playback > Sound Devices 744T (24 bit / 96kHz wav) > editing and mastering by David Minches, July 2022.
! t02 (1) @ 4:27 JG: “No dancing in the Lion’s Share. At least – nobody’s dancing in the Lion’s Share. [inaudible] dancing right around here [inaudible] I don’t know [inaudible]
! R: t05 some kind of noise in TNTDODD, not sure if it’s tape or equipment
! t06 (2) JG: “Thanks a lot folks. See y’all later.” Emcee: “Jerry Garcia, Merl Saunders, Tom Fogerty and Bill Kreutzmann. They’ll be back tomorrow night, for another two shows, along with Jerry Corbitt and Charlie Daniels. Come back and bring your friends. Thank you for comin’, and good night.”
~~~~~
Jerry Garcia & Merl Saunders
Lion’s Share
60 Red Hill Avenue
San Anselmo, CA 94960
September 25, 1971 (Saturday)
Judson MSR > HD 2022
–early show (7 tracks, 6 tunes, 51:56)–
e-t01. Introduction (1) [1:09]
e-t02. Save Mother Earth [11:38] ->
e-t03. Imagine [5:19] (2) [2:28]
e-t04. One Kind Favor [8:45] [1:25]
e-t05. I Was Made To Love Her [9:53] [0:32]
e-t06. Baby, What Do You Want Me To Do? [3:47] [0:04] %
e-t07. Biloxi [6:51] [0:06]
–late show (7 tracks, 51:55)–
l-t01. [0:15] Hi-Heel Sneakers [8:36] [1:10]
l-t02. Man-Child [10:21] ->
l-t03. Summertime [10:07] [1:14]
l-t04. That’s A Touch I Like [5:47] (3) [1:52]
l-t05. Annie Had A Baby [2:55] ->
l-t06. W-P-L-J [3:17] [0:13] %
l-t07. [0:19] The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down [5:40] (4) [0:09]
! ACT1: Jerry Garcia and Merl Saunders
! lineup: Jerry Garcia – electric guitar, vocals;
! lineup: Tom Fogerty – electric guitar, vocals;
! lineup: Merl Saunders – keyboards;
! lineup: John Kahn – electric bass;
! lineup: Bill Kreutzmann – drums.
JGMF:
! Recording: symbols: % = recording discontinuity; / = clipped song; // = cut song; … = fade in/out; # = truncated timing; [m:ss] = recorded event time. The recorded event time immediately after the song or item name is an attempt at getting the “real” time of the event. So, a timing of [m:ss] right after a song title is an attempt to say how long the song really was, as represented on this recording.
! Jerrybase: https://jerrybase.com/events/19710925
! db, mistakenly dated 9/24/71: https://etreedb.org/shn/4497 (“MSR>1C>D etc.”, via Ryan Shriver and Danny Metz); https://etreedb.org/shn/137584 (“MSR>DAT etc.”, via Paul Scotton and SIRMick); https://etreedb.org/shn/138213 (raw transfer of Scotton DAT). Prior to 8/9/2022, no sources have circulated dated 9/25/71, which is the correct date for this material.
! map: https://goo.gl/maps/FCaYZGNhk21VzhvF6
! JGBP: http://jerrygarciasbrokendownpalaces.blogspot.com/2012/06/lions-share-60-red-hill-avenue-san.html
! R: field recordist: Lou Judson
! R: field recording gear: PA line out > Viking 88
! R: field recording media: 2x Sony SLH-180 1/4″ x 7″ @7.5ips 1/4 trk stereo (tapes “GS7” and “GS8”)
! R: lineage: MSR Sony 854-4 playback > Sound Devices 744T (24 bit / 96kHz wav) > editing and mastering by David Minches, July 2022.
! e-t01 (1) JG: “Hey – whoever it is that controls the lights, could ya turn ’em down, these ones here? Ahh, yes. Keep it going … thanks, great. You can turn ’em down even farther … that’s good. [To band] Can you guys see well enough?” Tom: “Oh yeah, for sure.” Emcee: Let’s have a warm welcome for Jerry Garcia, Tom Fogerty, Merl Saunders, and … friends.” JG: “That’s, uh, John Kahn and Bill Kreutzmann, are the ‘friends’.” Emcee: “Thank you.” JG: “Don’t mention it.”
! P: e-t02 SME very slowly paced. @ 7:30 JG pedals in a little wah or whatever that is. Things getting melty in 9.
! e-t03 (2) Tom: “Can we get some beer and apple juice, please?” JG: “And a little bit of light – just the tiniest little bit” [some chuckles].
! R: e-t07 Biloxi patched in from shnid-137584. How it could be complete there and not here is a mystery …
! P: l-t01 HHS Tom’s buzzsaw tone fatigues my ears
! P: l-t02 Man-Child John starts rumbling fantastically in 6
! l-t04 (3) Tom: “Can we please have some beers and, uhh, two apple juices?”
! R: l-t07 TNTDODD in mono
! l-t07 (4) JG: “Thanks a lot. Good night.”
Leave a Reply